Welcome to Vol.82 of Email Advice in Your Inbox

Hi again, {{name|fellow sender}}!

Yep, Black Friday is a week from tomorrow (with Cyber Monday hot on its heels).

And somewhere right now, a newsletter operator is staring at a spreadsheet of every one of those previous buyers, webinar sign-ups, and giveaway entrants they've ever collected, thinking... why not send to all of them?

And we get it. Q4 is when everyone dusts off those old lists.

But before we email "every damn email address we have", there’s a little something you might wanna ask yourself first:

Who actually said yes?

Two regulators just answered that one the…expensive way, and neither of the businesses involved had bought a list (in case that’s what you’re wondering).

So if you've ever added a customer to your newsletter "because they'll probably want it", stick with us.

Because it’s time to check our receipts (the consent kind, that is)!


Header with an expired milk image stating "subscriber consent has a shelf life"

A Past Customer Isn't a Subscriber (Yet)

Yeah, you’ve probably got a list of everyone who's ever bought your offers. Now surely they'd want to hear about the Black Friday sale you’re running, wouldn’t they?

Unfortunately, though, technically, a past customer isn't a subscriber until they say so.

Buying from you, joining your webinar or even entering your giveaway is a yes to that thing. Your newsletter? Well, that’s a separate question (and the one an Australian telco just paid a lot to answer).


A$653,400 for saying "we miss you"

Between July and September 2025, SpinTel sent more than 32,000 marketing emails, without consent, to former customers urging them to come back.

SpinTel's argument? The old business relationship meant consent could be inferred. Some of those people had left up to 13 years earlier. (Thirteen years! Some of us haven't kept the same email address that long 😅)

The regulator disagreed, and an ACMA member said: "a previous business relationship did not automatically provide consent to send marketing messages".

The bill for that faux pas? An A$653,400 penalty, plus a three-year court-enforceable undertaking.

Yeesh, that’s a fair bit…

Over in Canada, Pizza Hut also just agreed to pay C$500,000 under an undertaking with the CRTC. The alleged issues? Messages without express or implied consent, unsubscribes not actioned within 10 business days, and some with no unsubscribe at all. As our friend Al at Spam Resource points out, an undertaking is "not a formal admission of guilt" either…

But notice what's missing from both of these? A bought list. These were "we already know these people" mistakes.

And we’re here to help you avoid making the same one, guys.


"Cool, but we're a newsletter, not a telco"

Fair point. But most newsletters we know have a pile of addresses that arrived without anyone asking for the newsletter:

  • buyers of a paid tier, template or course

  • webinar sign-ups and lead-magnet downloaders

  • event and workshop attendees

  • giveaway entrants

  • swap partners' lists and imports from an old platform or a partner

  • beehiiv or Substack recommendations (these folks did pick you, they just arrive with a fair bit less context, so that's more a welcome-sequence job)

Back in Vol. 79, we talked about the person who grabbed your lead magnet in 2024 and has since forgotten who you are. And in Vol. 37, we said it pretty plainly: "It's also not okay to opt-in subscribers who aren't aware that they're opting-in, or if you're assuming they can simply be added to your emails. Remember this."

So which of those actually said yes to the newsletter?


So what counts as a "yes"? (A very quick world tour)

The rules change with where your readers live (not only where you're based). We want to avoid making this a boring legal email, but here’s a quick TLDR:

  • UK: Consent first, plus a "soft opt-in" for your own customers (more on its rules below). The ICO says it "does not apply to prospective customers or new contacts", and a free download usually isn't a sale.

  • EU: "Prior consent", with the same customer exception. Each country sets its own rules, and some are stricter.

  • US: Mostly opt-out. You can email first, but you need a working unsubscribe (honoured within 10 business days) and a postal address.

  • Canada: Implied consent has a clock: two years after a purchase, six months after an enquiry.

  • Australia: Inferred consent needs "a provable, ongoing relationship", and the ACMA says it "does not cover sending messages after someone has just bought something from your business."

  • South Africa: Consent or a customer route, and the Information Regulator says "silence cannot mean consent".

Spot the pattern? Almost everywhere outside the US, the "customer" exception only covers people who:

  • bought (or nearly bought) from you

  • hear about your similar products

  • got an easy opt-out when you collected their address, and in every email since

Free downloads, giveaways and other people's lists usually don't make the cut.

And because the rules follow your readers, a South African newsletter with Canadian readers has CASL to think about too, as a rule of thumb.

Just a quick heads-up: we're email folks, not lawyers. This is us reporting what the regulators say, so check with someone qualified for your own list and the countries your readers live in. Just sayin’!


The platforms and inboxes are checking too

Do you think your platform doesn't care where your list came from?

Well, to give us an example here, beehiiv's Acceptable Use Policy requires affirmative consent, says lists shared by partners or affiliates don't meet it, and notes beehiiv may ask for proof (signup source, timestamp, method). Re-adding people who unsubscribed is prohibited too, "including attempting to re-permission the same recipient through another publication or list without a new, specific, affirmative opt-in".

Most platforms follow similar AUPs too.

Gmail and Yahoo also both want one-click unsubscribe from bulk senders, and Yahoo says unsubscribes should be actioned within 2 days.

So even where the law is relaxed, your platform and the inboxes aren't.


So, before Black Friday, check that shelf life

Consent has a shelf life. It can expire, it has to be provable, it only covers what someone agreed to, and it ends the moment they leave.

Here’s what we suggest you do before you start blasting on those BFCM emails (or dust off that old list for 2027):

1. Trace where every segment came from.

Tag each source: signup form, purchase, webinar, giveaway, swap, import, etc. If you can't say how and when someone said yes, you can't prove it, and regulators in Canada, Australia and South Africa all put the burden of proof on the sender.

2. Ask the unclear ones once, and properly (where you're allowed to).

Send one short re-permission email to the fuzzy ones and keep only those who say yes (doing nothing takes them off, never the other way round). As we said in Vol. 56, "Win-backs work best when they feel like an invitation, not a plea."

A big caveat, though. In Australia, the regulator says, "You cannot send an electronic message to ask for consent, because this is a marketing message." In South Africa, the law allows a single approach to a non-customer to ask, and only if they haven't said no before.

For some people, the best answer is to leave them off and invite them in via your website, receipt or thank-you page.

3. Make leaving fast, and make it stick everywhere.

One-click unsubscribe, plus a visible link. Act on it quickly: Yahoo says 2 days, Australia 5 working days, the US and Canada 10 business days.

Push every unsubscribe to every tool and vendor that mails for you (Spam Resource suggests following one request through your systems to check). And keep a "do not contact" list so old exports never sneak people back in. That’s always wise.


So, who's actually on your list?

If someone on your Black Friday send replied "how did you get my email?", could you show them the exact moment they said yes?

If not, that's this week sorted. And while you're digging, tell us the strangest place a list of yours came from (no judgement, we promise).

And remember, a smaller list that said yes beats a big one that never did (for your relationships, reputation and bank account).


Header for "Our favourite links"

What have we found to expand your email knowledge today?

Here are a few of our favourite links from across the email and business world, carefully curated just for you:

Find of the week ⭐

With the massive changes taking place in getting found on the internet, if you’re not showing up when folks using AI start searching…yeah, you’re probably not getting found.

The only way to show up, however, is if you’re actually getting recommended, so ask yourself this:

Does AI recommend you?

Your buyers now ask ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google's AI who to use, and they act on the few names it gives back.

Our friend Lilach Bullock’s free AI Visibility Checker shows you in about 30 seconds whether those AI engines name you, then gives you the exact steps to become the answer. (P.S. No sign-up needed for your grade).

And one more thing…

Support the team that supports these emails!

Remember Stripo’s interactive, gamified emails we raved about in Email Tools TLDR? They’re officially on ProductHunt today.

We tested them and, man, what a way to elevate your emails! Think gamification in an email, without your readers leaving their inbox...

Head on over and go show them some support here today, friends.

We're also constantly on the lookout for new resources, news, tools and links, so hit us up if you've got something valuable to feature!


The Flyover ad content and subscribe link

Subscribe to The Flyover for FREE!

Tired of biased headlines, endless scrolling, and news that takes
forever to read?

Join nearly 3 million readers who trust The Flyover for quick, fact-focused coverage of politics, business, sports, technology, and more.

Our editorial team reviews hundreds of sources every day and delivers only the stories that matter—without the spin, fluff, or agenda.

Stay informed in just minutes each morning and start your day ahead of the curve.

*By clicking below, you are subscribing to The Flyover's FREE daily newsletter and will begin receiving future editions in your inbox.


"Just for Fun" section header

Speaking of Black Friday…We're one week away.

Ready for that barrage of abandoned cart emails yet? 👀

No one:, Emails: Hey, you forgot about your cart - With a smiling Mark Zuckerberg peering through a window at the viewer


If you have any feedback or knowledge to share, hit us up here! Oh, and please share this email with your friends and colleagues if you think they'll find value over here.

Your feedback only makes us better.

Your friend in email,

Des