We obsess over subject lines, send times, and open rates. That’s cool and all, but there's one page almost every newsletter operator completely ignores.

And today's guest is here to make sure you're not one of them.

Meet Dylan Redekop, email growth maestro, and the legend behind the Growth Currency newsletter, and part-leader of the phenomenal Growth Currency Media/ Growth in Reverse team, alongside Chenell Basilio.

Dylan has some serious street cred, too! Having spent over 13 years in marketing, he not only sends good emails and shares great content, but also literally helps creative entrepreneurs grow, improve and monetise their emails.

Today, he's making the case for one of the most overlooked pages in your entire signup flow: the Thank-You page.

Let’s get stuck in to hear what he mentions about the mistakes most newsletters make, the things every Thank-You page should include (with real examples), and a plan to fix yours.

You’re not ready for this one!

Think about it: every new subscriber gets the chance to see it. So why wouldn't you make the most of it?

But to so many newsletter operators, the Thank-you page (TYP) is an afterthought.

In the context of this piece, a Thank-you page is the next page a new email subscriber sees after they sign up for your newsletter.

A proper Thank-you page can…

→ Drive first-party data with a simple survey
→ Drive revenue with an upsell, sponsor, affiliate, or offer
→ Build a waitlist
→ Build trust with a video or personal note
→ Drive engagement with a prompt to check their inbox

There are 3 major mistakes I see when it comes to sign-up flows and Thank-you pages.

Mistake #1: No Thank-you page.
It's worth repeating. Exactly zero people benefit from a missing Thank-you page. You don't. Your new subscribers don't. Add a Thank-you page redirect after your landing page sign-up.

Mistake #2: The "Success" Message
I see this one a lot. A new subscriber eagerly enters their email address and hits the 'subscribe' button… Only to stay on that page and see a message like "Your submission was successful." 🥱

Or you'll see the not-much-better "Success! Check your email to confirm your subscription." At least that message includes a CTA.

But how many folks even pay attention to this?

A redirect to a Thank-you page with the same message but in large letters is more attention-grabbing and more likely to get action.

Mistake #3: The "Subscription Confirmed" Page
This is a default page that a new subscriber is redirected to once they've confirmed their subscription. This is the ESP's default setting with double opt-in flows. But this page is another missed opportunity for a much more optimised thank-you type of page. The big takeaway is that you need to think through every new subscriber touch point.

1: Confirmation of what they just signed up for.
Did someone just sign up for a lead magnet? Confirm it. Tell them to click a link or check the email waiting in their inbox.
Did they sign up for your newsletter? Advise them to check their inbox ASAP and make sure it landed in their inbox.

BONUS: use a Sniper Link to get them to their inbox and find your welcome email instantly. Don't know how? Use this GPT to build one in 60 seconds →

2: Set an expectation.
You can't set too many expectations. Your landing page, thank-you page and welcome email should all reinforce what the reader can expect with your newsletter. This is your chance to get them excited for what's in store. Use social proof if you have any. Hype up your newsletter and get them eager to open your first email. Let them know when they'll get your next edition, how often, and remind them why they should care.

3: Pick a main CTA
Urging folks to check their inbox for your welcome email is the most common CTA for a Thank-you page. But maybe you want them to take another action, like checking out a resource, a sales page, a video, a piece of content or something else.

4: Signal personality.
Be different. Show your humanity. Get people intrigued. Even if your newsletter doesn't have a "face" (think daily news-focused newsletters like 1440 or Morning Brew), they still have personality and a unique voice. Personality is the antidote to AI slop.

5: (Optional) An upsell, referral, survey, or waitlist moment (the advanced play)
Got a low-ticket offer to promote? Use your thank-you page to share it. Or do what The Assist does and run a quick survey to get first-party subscriber data. Want to refer your readers to check out another newsletter (perhaps as part of a collab or partnership?) – then add it to your Thank-you page. Want to feature a sponsor or affiliate deal on your Thank-you page? That's what Marketing Examined and Half Baked do. There are no wrong answers here.

Why We Buy

Katelyn Bourgoin is a marketing guru.

I love her Why We Buy thank-you page because it has a ton of personality, it's super straightforward, and it has a powerful incentive with the "surprise for you" messaging that is going to get the reader from thinking "meh" to clicking over to their inbox immediately.

THE TYP ELEMENTS CHECKLIST

✅ Confirmation: With bold capital letters (“You're In!”)
✅ CTA: “Now go check your inbox – like right now”
✅ Sets Expectations: Not really, except that it suggests you're “not going to wanna miss it”
✅ Shows Personality: WWB logo with a brightly coloured background, on brand with Katelyn's image for added personality
⚠️ Advanced Play (upsell, referral, waitlist bonus): Kind of - the 'surprise for you' is a free resource.

TYP Improvements:
→ adding a Sniper link to the page so her email can be found in one click.
→ making the incentive messaging more prominent or highlighted, as it could be easily missed

Marketing Examined

Alex Garcia optimises everything. So it's no surprise he's optimised the sh*t out of his thank-you page for Marketing Examined.

THE TYP ELEMENTS CHECKLIST

✅ Confirmation: “Here's How To Get The Most Out Of Your Subscription”
❌ Sets Expectations: n/a
✅ CTA: “Can You Do Me One Quick Favour?” and includes a Sniper link
✅ Shows Personality: “Holy Sh*t. You're amazing.”
✅ Advanced Play: (below the fold, not pictured above) They are running a giveaway for a sponsor. So ME is already driving revenue before you've even got an email from them.

TYP Improvements:
→ The page actually has a LOT going on. Alex could tighten things up, or vibe code some gamification with the progress bar (complete a step and get a check)

SPI

SPI (Smart Passive Income) is Pat Flynn's content business. What I love about this Thank-you page is the opportunity to take the SPI Community ($49/month) for a test drive for one dollar.

This is a huge revenue driver for SPI, so it makes sense they are promoting it right on their TYP.

THE TYP ELEMENTS CHECKLIST

✅ Confirmation: “Congrats! You are enrolled! You're so smart!”
✅ CTA: Multiple! “Join Now For $49 $1” button
✅ Sets Expectations: “You'll receive the first email next Tuesday.”
✅ Shows Personality: Copy and messaging on brand with things like “You're so smart!” and “But hurry, baby!”
✅ Advanced Play: Driving urgency with a $1 offer (saving ~98% to join their community) — SPI is driving revenue on their Thank-you page.

TYP Improvements:
→ Like Marketing Examined's TYP, this one is also pretty long — but it's more justified in this case given it's a sales page.
→ an image of Pat and/or Liz (his community manager) above the fold could help with context and trust

Half Baked

Half Baked is a newsletter for solopreneurs that features “Startup ideas from the world's best Investors, innovators, builders (etc)”.

They are going after a more B2B audience, so having a compelling affiliate offer for a product like Slack makes a lot of sense.

Half Baked uses paid growth quite heavily, so I love that they're trying to recoup some ad spend post-sign-up.

THE TYP ELEMENTS CHECKLIST

✅ Confirmation: “Welcome to Half Baked.”
✅ CTA: “Grab Your Discount →”
❌ Sets Expectations: n/a – no mention of when I'll get the first newsletter or how often it will be sent
✅ Shows Personality: The gif of Darragh waving emits some personality
✅ Advanced Play: Promoting a Slack partnership or affiliate link on the sign-up page is low-risk and high-reward. They're driving revenue without sending a single edition.

TYP Improvements:
→ Darragh and the HB team could set some expectations and get people excited for their first edition

Growth In Reverse

Chenell from Growth In Reverse blew up ~3 years ago when she was publishing deep dives on newsletter creators every week.

And the dives were DEEP. She'd spend 20- 40 hours researching and putting them together.

So it makes sense that one of the first actions she gets new subs to take is to check out one of her most popular deep dives.

THE TYP ELEMENTS CHECKLIST

✅ Confirmation: “Hey! You Made It!
✅ CTA: “Start →” button
✅ Sets Expectations: Quick explainer of what she does: “I write deep dives on newsletter creators to find out how they grew from 0 to 50k+ subscribers… You can expect the next issue soon, but in the meantime…”
✅ Shows Personality: Image of her smiling and waving (friendly, welcoming)
❌ Advanced Play: n/a

TYP Improvements:
→ Chenell is missing out on an Advanced Play opportunity here, given she has several low- and medium-ticket offers. Even more, she could partner with an affiliate or sponsor to brand the page with a valuable & compelling offer her subscribers would love (like with Kit, Senja, beehiiv, etc)

Creator Science

Jay Clouse is a prolific creator with a popular podcast, membership, and YouTube channel of 100k+ subscribers. But when he started out, all he had was his newsletter.

So it's a safe assumption that he's experimented with many TYP strategies (it's not called Creator Science for nothin' 😉)

What I appreciate most about Jay's Creator Science thank-you page is the focus on making sure his subscribers get his emails — in their inboxes. He even lays out an image of what they should see or search for in their inbox.

THE TYP ELEMENTS CHECKLIST

✅ Confirmation: Jay uses double opt-in, so this is more like an 'Almost There' page: “One more step! I need you to confirm your email address.”
✅ CTA: “If you use Gmail, you can use this link.” – Jay uses a sniper link that will take the user directly to their Gmail inbox with a search filter built into the link parameters. Want to add one to your own TYP? Use this Custom GPT to build yours in 60 seconds →
⚠️ Sets Expectations: Kinda… Jay shares what to look for in your inbox, but nothing about when to expect his newsletter, how often, or what to get excited about.
✅ Shows Personality: not above the fold, but once you scroll down, there's a GIF of Jay doing his best impression of a popular meme.
❌ Advanced Play: n/a

TYP Improvements:
→ Jay could do a better job setting expectations here to get people amped for his newsletter—and THEN suggest “But you better go confirm your email address first so you can actually get my emails!”
→ Jay also has a swath of options for Advanced Plays but doesn't use any of them here.

Step 1: Set Up the Redirect.
If you don't have a dedicated TYP at all, this is your only job today. Log into your ESP, find the post-signup redirect setting, and point it to a real page. A blank canvas beats no canvas.

Step 2: Add the Non-Negotiables.
Confirmation + expectation setting + one clear CTA + a sniper link. That's your baseline. Four things. If your TYP has all four, you're already ahead of most newsletters.
Bonus: ask subscribers to add your email address to their contacts - it takes five seconds for them, and it's one of the highest-leverage deliverability moves you can make. The easiest way is to get them to hit reply with one word (to make it a low lift).

Step 3: Pick your Advanced Play.
Survey, upsell, referral, affiliate, sponsor — choose one and add it. This is where your TYP stops being a formality and starts being a growth asset. Even a simple “know someone who'd love this?” referral nudge can compound over time.

Your thank-you page is the only page every single subscriber will see. Make it count.

Your friend,

Dylan

P.S. Make sure you keep learning from Dylan! Seriously, his emails are some of the gold-standard stuff we read every time, and you should too, so make sure you sign up!

Thinking differently about your thank-you page after that?

If you have any feedback or knowledge to share, click here! Oh, and please share this email with your friends and colleagues if you think they'll find value over here.

Your feedback only makes us better.

Your friend in email,

Des